[Chapter 1] [Chapter 2] [Chapter 3] [Chapter 4] [Chapter 5] [Chapter 6] [Chapter 7] [Chapter 8][Chapter 9] [Chapter 10] [References] [Links] [Home] 
COLLABORATIVE TEACHING:
SPECIAL EDUCATION FOR INCLUSIVE CLASSROOMS
Price, Mayfield, McFadden, and Marsh
Copyright © 2000-2001 Parrot Publishing, L.L.C.

CHAPTER 8

SECONDARY PROGRAMMING 

OBJECTIVES

  1. Define the holistic approach to curriculum development.
  2. Describe reflective teaching practice.
  3. Describe and provide examples of skill-based, subject-centered approach, such as the integrated curriculum, mastery learning, and tutorial instruction.
  4. Define and list the components of effective instruction.
  5. Describe and provide examples of student-centered learning, such as Cooperative Learning, peer tutors, Whole Language, multi-age grouping, and flexible groups.
The comprehensive secondary school encompasses two kinds of curriculum efforts and philosophies, one geared to the college bound and the other to work preparation. Although the majority of U.S. adolescents go to work rather than college, high schools usually fail to address the needs of students who do not attend college. These students leave high school without the skills they need to be successful in the workplace. The guidance program is set up to aid the college bound, while vocational counseling and job placement services are neglected or non-existent (American Association for Curriculum and Development, 1996). The secondary curriculum seems more resistant to modification in most schools than the elementary school, especially since the education reform movement, because it is organized around subject areas and departments, much like a university. In such cultures there is less attention to the needs of students, less collaboration, and often more competition for resources.

The effects can be measured in terms of student attitudes toward school. The National Center for Education Statistics (1995) reported that many secondary students characterize high school as having uncaring and poor teachers and unfair discipline. About 25% believed teachers are not interested in students, and 33% said teachers would not listen to them. The main reason reported for leaving school by dropouts was they did not like school (58% male and 44% female), many of them reporting having conflicts with teachers. Schumaker and Deshler (1995) contend that enrollments of students with disabilities in regular classes of the secondary school continue to result in high rates of failure and dropping out, apparently for social reasons. Expecting regular classroom teachers to deal with the needs of students with disabilities by modification of the curriculum, space, and instructional methods will likely be a problem under traditional organizational arrangements.
 

Subject Areas of the Curriculum

The traditional curriculum of the secondary school is organized-- by subject areas and departments--around English, mathematics, science, social studies, fine arts and vocational programs. Mathematics is ultimately divided into geometry, algebra, and pre-calculus. Science is split between the physical sciences and biology. Reading drops out as a subject, except for occasional reference to study skills, and students may become immersed in English ranging from parsing sentences to writing themes and studying literature. Social studies focus on history, and there is now a trend to reemphasize geography. Fine arts become an elective for most high school students, who may play in the orchestra or the band or engage in specialized visual arts.

The instructional challenge to any teacher is to make subject matter as relevant to students as possible. In the past, resource room teachers have attempted to assist mainstream teachers to organize instruction for special education students, but more often they worked directly with the students, either presenting alternative instruction of some sort or providing tutorial assistance.

Although specific graduation requirements vary from one state to another, the typical course of study is about 22 credits earned in grades 9-12 to meet minimum requirements and qualify for graduation. A typical sequence might look like this:

GRADE 9
English 9 - 1 full year
Social 9 - 1 full year
Science 9 - 1 full year
Algebra/Transition Math - 1 full year
Physical Education 9 - 1 full year
Keyboarding I - 1/2 semester

GRADE 10
English 10 - 1 full year
American History - 1 full year
Physical Education/Health 10 - 1 full year

GRADE 10-12

Science Electives - 1 = 2 semesters
Math Electives - 1 = 2 semesters
Other Electives (grades 9-12) - 7 = 14 semesters

GRADE 11
Communications - 1/2 semester
American Literature/Technical Writing - 1/2 semester
World History - 1/2 semester
World Geography/Affairs - 1/2 semester

GRADE 12
English: One of four options - 1 full year
Social Studies: American Government - 1/2 semester
and American Political System. - 1/2 semester
Health - 1/2 semester

English and language arts

The language arts curriculum at the secondary level is less concerned with reading instruction and writing. There is commonly a succession of courses that cover the college-bound content or alternative courses with a more practical emphasis. In some schools there have been attempts to integrate English with other subjects, such as history and science. There have also been variations or tracks: regular, practical, advanced placement, and vocational.

Science

The traditional course sequence for science for college preparation has been as follows:

9 General science
10 Biology
11 Chemistry
12 Physics

The pattern was established for college bound students, but all students are required to take a prescribed number of courses, more in recent years due to "high standards" in the curriculum. There are also Advanced Placement (AP) and honors courses for the more academically talented. Attempts have been made to integrate science with other subjects, most notably the attempts of the National Science Foundation.

Mathematics

The traditional mathematics program is for college preparation and follows this sequence:

Grade  9 - General math or algebra
Grade 10- Geometry
Grade 11- Advanced Algebra
Grade 12- Trigonometry/pre-calculus

Change in recent years has been an attempt to alter the way mathematics is taught, being more action-relevant, including the introduction of computers and electronic calculators. Although most students are able to demonstrate competency in computational skills, the overwhelming majority is incapable of solving problems requiring several successive steps (Dossey et al. 1988). This has caused a closer examination of teaching and the school curriculum, with recommendations for changes in curricula, teaching methodologies, and assessment techniques (Steen, 1989).

The reason students do well in computation is because that is what they are taught. Math is dependent upon feedback and corrective learning, more so than subjects dependent upon reading and memorization, although teaching strategies in mathematics often emphasize teaching by telling, rote, and memorization of rules. If students miss key concepts in mathematics and sufficient practice in applications, failure may be certain because the foundation for future learning is absent. There have been many recommendations to reform how mathematics is taught.

Social studies

Social studies commonly includes the following sequence:

Grade 9 - Citizenship
Grade10- World history
Grade11- Problems of the American Government

In most schools, teachers prefer working with the college bound and resist teaching the "lower" tracks. The vocational programs are often seen as the "dumping grounds" for those without academic talent (GAO, 1992), although even in the vocational programs the teachers seem to prefer students with more academic talent.

A rather bleak picture has been painted about the nature of secondary school instruction. The subject-centered curriculum and the tradition of the lecture have been indicted for insensitivity to individual needs. There have been attempts at more student-centered approaches and modifications of various types, including more small group or individualized activities.

The instructional tasks of the teacher and the ability of students to profit from instruction depend on the quality of presentation and the ability for everyone to hear and understand. Many students who are disruptive, withdrawn, frustrated, or resigned to failure may be unable to see and hear clearly in the classroom, in addition to being generally disinterested. Therefore, modifications must be based on changing the teacher's presentation.

The Secondary Environment

The task for the student with disabilities in the regular classroom environment is difficult, especially students with auditory, attention, auditory processing, or comprehension problems. Students must have access to multiple sources of information. Information should be audible and/or visible to improve understanding and comprehension. Under conditions of a regular classroom, the student and teacher must engage in a process of communication, most of it emanating from the teacher. Regardless of other factors, such as the motivation or the special services provided by special education personnel, any child who cannot see and hear clearly will be penalized.

Assuming that opportunity and motivation are high, the process can, nonetheless, be undermined by poor instruction. Assuming instructional quality to also be high, any environmental problem can cause the process to collapse, notably noise and lack of visual cues. Instructional strategies---deductive and inductive methods, lectures, questions, and practice, and group and discussion methods---are critically dependent upon the ability to hear and to see clearly.

Subjects at the secondary level are often based on simplified instruction by the teacher but governed by textbooks that contain stifling content, sources of information that are incoherent within the learner's experiences.

Knowledge in Isolation

A major problem of the current curriculum is both "..the psychology experiment and the school curriculum focus on memory for isolated concepts and facts, thereby fragmenting learning to such a degree that results are inapplicable in authentic real- world contexts" (Iran-Nejad & Marsh, 1993). The two assumptions in current educational theory and practice are: (a) knowledge is a separate product (Iran-Nejad & Marsh, 1993) and (b) knowledge should be simplified and isolated (Iran-Nejad & Ortony, 1984). The first assumption is based on the premise that knowledge exists separately from the central nervous system or the mind and, thus, can exist in some complete form outside the student, where it can be transferred, stored, and reproduced later in the brain. The typical school curriculum is based on such a structure; important knowledge is often stated in behavioral objectives. The second assumption implies that complex knowledge can be learned simply by breaking it into pieces for easy consumption by learners.

Compartmentalized Curriculum

Separated by disciplines, mathematics is unrelated to science, science is unrelated to language arts, and so forth, and each "subject" becomes isolated and distinct as bodies of information to be memorized independently. And the simplification process does not end there. Teachers are separated into departments by discipline and pupils are grouped on the basis of ability and tracked through the system.

In the traditional classroom the child is not permitted to use whole-experiences or learn dynamically but is often limited to narrow "active" processes: concentrating to pay attention, posing self-questions or creating mnemonics, and following a predictable path to the correct answers.

Viewing traditional teaching from the child's point of view, classroom learning is mysterious, confusing, and arbitrary. As Pechman (1992) notes: ". . . schools try to teach children to use the formal tools of academic disciplines---vocabulary, mathematical formulas, dictionaries, scientific procedures---but many children find few opportunities outside of school to practice what they are taught. The resulting inauthenticity of classroom activity makes it difficult for children to see how school learning applies to their lives" (p. 33).

The quality of a student's education is the result of the school learning environment and the importance attached to education by the student and his or her family. The learning climate of the school can have significant impact on students, depending upon teachers' attitudes and behaviors and those of peers. Obviously if students come prepared to learn, they will have a better experience, but the environment must be conducive to learning through encouragement and support.
 
 Students With Intellectual Disabilities
 A Resource Guide for Teachers:  Fostering Inclusion

In addition to the many things that teachers already do to foster a positive classroom environment, you might find some of these
ideas helpful.

To create a positive classroom environment:

  •  build a strong, supportive social environment in your classroom.
  • set expectations for the student with special needs that are  similar to those for all of the other students in your classroom (social, emotional and behavioural).
  • discipline the student with special needs when necessary.
  • create a support system for the student at recess and lunch times, and for extracurricular activities (e.g., buddy system).
  • provide all students with opportunities for making choices throughout the day (e.g., games, group tasks, centre activities).
  • provide for circle times or regular class meetings so students can talk about feelings, concerns, ideas, successes.
  • involve all students in problem solving.
  • pair students for some jobs so that assistance is available if needed.
  • find a role for all students in the class regardless of disabilities (e.g., a student who is unable to run a race could be timekeeper).
  • communicate positive attitudes towards students with disabilities through your own interactions, comments and behaviour.
  • recognize the successes of the student with disabilities as a contributing member of the class.
________
Source:  Part of a website page
Minstry of Education
British Columbia, Canada

Modification of Instruction

Few high schools have adopted student-centered models because the most common innovation in recent years has been the tendency to experiment with "time" models, such as various block-scheduling techniques. It is also less likely that there will be "team" teaching between classroom and special education teachers. The resource room model and/or the consulting model of special education delivery are likely to be the preferred options, although continuing litigation, court decisions, and financial complications may cause more school districts to consider inclusion in secondary schools. Regular classroom teachers in the various subject areas can use similar strategies that were recommended for elementary schools. In addition to the accommodations mentioned previously, which may benefit the individual students, there are many other modifications that can be employed. Yeager (1995) reported that teachers taught to use various teaching strategies, such as advanced organizers, study guides, visual organizers, and learning strategies, provide better instruction for all students in an inclusive room.

Topical Outlines

A topical outline is a simple device that can provide significant information to students and parents. Clarifying what content will be covered in a unit or section is easily done by these methods.

Glossaries and Summaries A glossary can be useful in any kind of subject matter or content. Students are going to encounter many unfamiliar terms, and this is one way of modifying direct instruction that does not require a great deal of the teacher's time.

Cognitive Organizers

Like pre-reading questions, cognitive organizers can be used with a unit of instruction to prepare students for the "big ideas" to be examined in the course of study.
 
 
VISTA

The VISTA process includes four major activities:

  1. general preparation (e.g., forming a team, learning about team members' skills, getting to know the student, reading the VISTA manual),
  2.  getting ready for the VISTA Meeting (e.g., determining the components of the student's educational program),
  3. having the VISTA meeting (e.g., considering potential support services as a team, evaluating suggestions based on criteria, reaching consensus on educationally necessary services), and 
  4. next steps after the VISTA meeting (e.g., subgroups do more refined planning, implementing team decisions, evaluating the impact of support services). 
From Michael Giangreco's web page

Study Guides

A true study guide is a comprehensive manual of all assignments, expectations, and information about "due dates" and examinations. Study guides can be helpful to parents and tutors who work with students.

Visual Aids

Too much reliance in the classroom on oral presentation can defeat the instructional goals of the teacher, but oral presentation may be enhanced if the lesson is accompanied by visual illustrations. Any kind of visual information presented by the teacher to accompany the lesson can support the major points presented, maintain attention, and improve comprehension. Graphics, actual scenes, pictures, and large text fonts can produce higher achievement and assist students in generating mental frameworks of knowledge.

Acoustical Treatment

A good acoustical treatment or amplification of the teacher's voice in the classroom can do much to improve clarity and understanding. This is especially effective in secondary classrooms, which are larger and may have more students.

Homework

Completing homework and bringing the appropriate materials to class may be indications of the student's motivation. If the majority of students are prepared, teachers can devote most of their time to teaching. Most subjects in secondary school have a great deal of assigned homework. Depending upon the needs and abilities of the student as expressed in the IEP, homework should be reasonable and its purposes clearly related to instructional goals. Homework should be graded. Walberg (1991) maintains that homework can have a significant effect on achievement.

Testing and Alternative Assessment

Many secondary classes based evaluation on teacher-made tests, usually objective formats. Alternatives to these tests, which may benefit all students, including three types of performance- based assessment: performances, portfolios, and projects.

Performances

According to Price and Marsh (1995), performance may be simple or complex, intermediate or summative. A child may demonstrate knowledge of addition (regrouping) by using concrete objects instead of a test item on a paper. A student may classify objects, such as Venn diagrams, plants, animals, or perform more complex tasks, such as setting up a database. While a student may perform a musical piece, the same strategy can be applied in many skills and subject areas. Rather than taking a printed test to check reading skills, the child may read (perform) a passage or tape record oral reading, for example. Recitations, oral reports, and group presentations lend themselves to performances in social studies, foreign languages, mathematics and science, and other parts of the curriculum. This can vary with the imagination of the teacher and the students. Any knowledge or skill that can be demonstrated may has the potential for a performance: oral presentation, lab demonstration, reading, debate, dance, or dramatization.

Portfolios

Portfolio assessment is appropriate for on going evaluation, such as writing, reading and fine arts skills. The portfolio is a way to physically store work of students, which can include video or audiotapes of performances. Even the work that is not written can be videotaped and placed in the "portfolio," which may be nothing more than a box. The portfolio is a collection of work assembled by a student over a long period of time. Portfolios are used for science, mathematics, language arts, literacy, and the arts. Portfolios could include samples of students' paintings, drawings, stories, letters, poems, lists, signs, handwriting, and use of numbers. Portfolios, collected frequently over a period of time, can serve as a collection of work to show a student's achievements. They are based on multiple sources of information that can be collected over a year or several years in the school setting. Therefore, the work can give a developmental history of the pupil and lead to predictions about potential. The documentation amassed in a collection can contain both the best work and the ordinary work of the student.

Portfolios may consist of audiotapes, videotapes, written works, artwork, sculpture, photographs and many other forms. An active portfolio assessment will soon take up much space, requiring considerations to be made about how long items are kept. As technology is becoming more available and affordable, it is possible to store many items in a secondary format, such as videotape or digitized video. Sophisticated development of assessment items may also improve delivery and use of items for teachers (Price & Marsh, 1995).

Projects

To assess the ability to reason, gather and organize facts and ideas, and to provide an integrated work, projects may be used. A project may be a problem-solving approach that entails the presentation of a problem that must be solved by applying theories and formulas. Problems may be in science, math, and social studies, for example. A project can consist of a short- or long-term activity of an individual student or a team that results in a product that represents some considerable effort. Depending upon the teacher's goals and the student's capabilities or interests, projects can be very simple or quite complex. Either as a separate subject area or an integrated product, a project can be prepared in many forms. Students can create original written works, photographic essays, musical productions, dances, and technical-type papers (Price & Marsh, 1995).

Considerations about Dealing with Classroom Instruction

Regardless of the of program or nature of the class, at the secondary level the students will be required or expected to read, listen, and take notes.

Attending to lectures/discussions

The student's primary task is to sit, look at the teacher, and remain attentive. As students get older, they seem to be able to do this more skillfully. Although elementary teachers talk a lot, they cannot hold the attention of all pupils for long periods of time. A lot of group activities and seatwork are used to good measure. However, at the secondary level the expectations are that students will endure several hours of lecture-type instruction and most can do it rather well. Those who cannot conform to expectations will be easily noticed. Such factors as the tolerance of teachers and the norms for classroom disruption determine whether students who have problems attending will be punished or reprimanded for certain unacceptable behaviors. Students who exceed the limits willfully or who appear to be disrespectful, disinterested, or glib will attract the attention of students and teachers, and they may be punished. Part of the problem is that this may change from class to class. Some teachers are much less tolerant of the same behaviors that are acceptable in another classroom.

This also highlights the main problem for the adjustment of a lot of pupils with disabilities at the secondary level. In the elementary grades there are work stations, work centers, small groups, and a variety of activities. In many secondary classrooms there is just one large class listening to (or watching) the teacher. It is in this situation that most problems can be expected for many students with disabilities, those who cannot understand what the teacher is talking about or who cannot pay attention for a class period or enter into classroom discussions. Although the courts have ruled that teachers must adjust their instruction to accommodate such differences, many teachers will regard this as totally inappropriate. Many teachers who do not know how to organize instruction any other way do not consider the fact that the classroom could be organized differently, such as using learning centers instead of lecture.

Note-taking

Students are usually expected to maintain notes on classroom activities, although there may be little effort to teach students how and why notes are taken, A clear record of salient point of classroom discussion can be very useful for learning and preparation for performance. Many students will not be able to take notes because of a variety of problems. Alternatives may be used, such as having someone share notes with the student or by making tape recordings. Both of these techniques are less than satisfactory due to the unreliability of note-takers and the fact that some teachers dislike being recorded. Also, tape recordings are not helpful because the student has to literally listen to the entire class all over again, like sitting through class twice.

Grading

Grading is a problem. Despite the many reform efforts and appeals for alternative forms of assessment, the practice of assigning grades and giving report cards is relatively unchanged. Letter grades for most types of student-centered programs are incongruous. Given the political and parental pressure for grades, it is difficult to change. Letter grades are not always correlated with any standards, even within the same school. Thus, an "A" in biology at one school or in a particular class may not represent the same thing in a different biology class. Many teachers are likely to award grades based on comparisons to other students, which may put some students with disabilities at an even greater disadvantage.

If educators question the value of letter grades or take the position that letter grades should not conform to the bell curve, they are vulnerable to the criticism of attempting to lower standards. To assure that there is a spread among scores, many teachers revert to a very complex system of awarding points, including neatness, promptness, and subjective criteria, none of which relate to what a student knows. For students with disabilities, due to the IEP, it should be possible to insist that the student's performance be listed in terms of progress toward specific objectives, which could be a list of skills or checklist, portfolios, participation in class discussion, class projects, oral reports, anecdotal records of student performance, daily logs of student activities, and modified tests.

Teachers and parents will be concerned about how students will be evaluated in the classroom, especially with respect to grading practices, and if the IEP will be used as a method to evaluate the teacher. Should schools prohibit letter grades for students by using the IEP to state alternative assessment? Children with an IEP have specified activities that must be pursued, so if the child fails, who is at fault? Does a letter grade reflect the teacher's opinion, measured differences among students in the same class, schoolwide standards and norms, or individualized accomplishment on criterion-referenced examinations? Are written examinations the only valid way of determining performance, or should alternative assessment measures be accepted? Should students with disabilities, who are given consultation and mentoring through some type of enrichment and/or academic support program, be allowed to make the same grades as students who receive no special assistance? Should students with disabilities be required to compete with nondisabled peers? Does the IEP, which determine the expected outcomes, dictate a grade if objectives are met?

In a study of sixth and eighth-grade mainstreamed students, Selby and Murphy (1992) examined the tests and letter grades used by teachers and found that students tended to feel helpless in attempts to earn high grades but blamed themselves for the low grades they received. Putnam (1992) examined 360 teacher-made tests used in English, math, science, and social studies in junior high and discovered the most frequent type of question was knowledge level asked in a multiple choice format.

The school should assure that the grading an testing procedures employed do not reflect the child's disability and that the child has ample opportunity to learn the skills and to demonstrate competence, even if through alternative means.

Modification by Means of Student-Centered Learning Models

Individualized Learning Situations

By providing students with comprehensive learning guides, a student may progress through a curriculum at his or her own rate. Not bound by the class schedule, an advanced student can move quickly and get onto more advanced subject matter. For those with slower paces, the flexibility of deadlines for marking progress and completing assignments reduces stress and anxiety. While this may be more useful in schools where some form of block scheduling is used, it can be used in a traditional high school setting. Built into the guide would be all assignments, activities, explanations, and even ways to complete specific tasks, such as meeting with peer groups, small groups, and completing individual activities.

Year-Round Schooling

Year-round education is an alternative to the traditional nine-month school year, partly for economic reasons. While school enrollments at the elementary level are increasing, communities are much less willing to support tax increases to provide sufficient buildings. By adopting a year-round model, schools can offer education more economically and not need to build new facilities. This may provide more options for families of children with disabilities who may plan activities over 12 months instead of only nine.

The School Within a School

Especially popular in large schools, the school is actually organized as if there are several independent schools that happen to share the same facility. Each "school" has the flexibility to have its own curriculum, personnel, and way of organizing. The students may spend a number of years with the same peers and the same teachers, developing a sense of community. Other options can be used within this context, depending on each "school," including individualization, continuous progress, and adjusting for needs of pupils with disabilities (see McLeod, 1996). This model can be useful at the secondary level for accommodating the needs of many students with disabilities.

Alternative Assessment

Described elsewhere, alternative assessment can focus on what students can eventually learn, rather than on intermediate test scores, and both the teacher and student can be directly involved in selecting assessment activities.

Curriculum-Based Assessment

A norm-referenced test, a predominant form of school assessment, will not tell what a student can or cannot do, or what a student has or has not learned; rather it tells the relative standing of the student compared with those who established the norms. It is difficult to characterize the performance of the student in terms of normative test scores. By contrast, a criterion-referenced test is based on the sequence of skills in a particular area of the curriculum, and it is possible to determine what a student actually knows or can do. Criterion-referenced tests and curriculum-based assessment (CBA), in which the items are much more numerous, can permit information about each student at important junctures rather than how the student stacks up against others. Specific curriculum steps can be identified for the student, instructional approaches tailored, and extraordinary progress made because teacher and student are constantly on task, particularly in monitoring achievement toward curricular objectives and determining instructional plans. Computers could provide the mechanism for improved student achievement and reduced clerical tasks.

Vocational Education

Increasing numbers of secondary programs are adopting vocational models for students with disabilities. In spite of the trend, there is no clear evidence that such programs are particularly effective in getting good jobs for the majority of students. The vocational program resists becoming a "dumping" ground for academic castoffs, but only 30% of students who complete high school intend to go to college. There is a real sense of concern and urgency about improving vocational options in the secondary curriculum for all students because of the global economy.

Vocational success seems to be an implied promise of American education. All students are encouraged to remain in school with the expectation that on entering the work force, their potential for earned income will have a direct positive relationship to the number of years spent in school. There is a relationship between employment and years in school, better than that between employment and academic achievement, but the ability to obtain and hold a job is more directly related to other factors. For many students, possession of a diploma merely assures entrance to more advanced training that will ultimately lead to employment. Many other students will receive virtually all training for an occupation from an employer after being hired. The diploma is a device used to screen applicants, but it does not really represent any particular universal skills.

Skills in Vocational Education

U.S. Department of Labor Recommended Skills

The problems of skills have been considered by a number of groups and agencies. The common goals promoted by the U.S. Department of Labor, called SCANS, for the Secretary's Commission on Achieving Necessary Skills Secretary's Commission on Achieving Necessary Skills (SCANS, 1991), have been used in vocational programs to address the needs of a new era. SCANS indicates that workers in the new economy must be able to do the following:

  1. Identify, organize, plan, and allocate resources - time, money, materials and facilities, and human resources.
  2. Work with others by participating as a team member, serving clients/customers, negotiating, and working with diversity.
  3. Acquire and use information.
  4. Work with and operate effectively within social organizations, and technological systems.
  5. Work with a variety of technologies.
  6. Contribute to the development of reading, writing, listening, speaking, and mathematical systems.
  7. Contribute to the development of thinking creatively, making decisions, solving problems, and reasoning.
School-to-Work Transition

Due to the increasing demands for skills and the disappearance of high paying low-skilled jobs, the School-to-Work Opportunities Act of 1994 was passed to consolidate employment and training legislation grants for states. School-to-work is a new vision of vocational training for secondary schools that uses a comprehensive, community-wide effort to assist students prepare for careers.

Apprenticeships

Drawing inspiration from Europe, primarily Germany, there are attempts to develop youth apprenticeship programs that offer relevant, work-based learning to noncollege-bound youth. Unlike a work experience program, this program intends to connect students to future employers, prepare high-skill jobs with a combination of courses and work experiences, and provide a full- time job at graduation.

There have been discussions in recent years about adopting a program of skill certification to be imposed on high schools, a part of the reform movement that would put meaning into the diploma. In other words, in addition to a diploma, a student would earn a certificate specifying competencies he or she can offer an employer. The problem with this is jobs skills change so rapidly it is not very practical. This is essentially what happens in apprenticeship programs, but the employer is responsible for much of the skill training.

Many jobs that exist today will disappear. Many that will exist are yet unknown. It is clear that persons who may be able to secure employment will need more technical skills. For students with disabilities, there is a danger that many will be technologically obsolete in the work force. Jobs that many such persons now hold will be replaced by automation, and there will be competition for these jobs from workers who have no disabilities.

The shifting nature of the work force is a problem for vocational education and the required equipment is expensive, then suddenly obsolete. Whereas American history courses or trigonometry will remain relatively unchanged, the latest vocational training will use equipment and software that will be out of date in a year or so. Technological changes can rapidly eliminate many jobs and rapidly create a demand for new one, which causes the school to be out of step with the job market. Vocational education must continuously change to meet changing demands. This is difficult and expensive.

Another problem is that vocation education, and career education to some extent, is stigmatized by the types of students who have been placed in vocational programs. Resnick and Wirtz (1996) reported that in 1990, students in vocational tracks took less coursework in English, history, social studies, math, science, languages, and computer science than students in academic programs, and half of the vocational students took remedial mathematics.

Without strong support students with minimal academic competency will not necessarily fare any better in vocational education than in the general curriculum. Some aspects of the vocational curriculum can be exceedingly technical and complex, and much more difficult than some of the content in regular academic classes.

The types of settings in which vocational programming may exist dictates what kinds of jobs will be included in the vocational training efforts. Schools that are located in large, urban areas present different opportunities that those in sampler communities. The selection of vocational education models depends on demographic characteristics, commitment of the district to vocational education, available resources, and other factors. In the general, there are high-cost training programs that require the investment of large sums of monies and personnel. The low-cost programs may be more easily offered but may be of much less usefulness to students.

Objectives for Planning Vocational Programs

Vocational education should be available on a continuum of career education experiences provided for students. Appropriate prevocational experiences should be provided to prepare each student for placement in vocational education. Every student should have the opportunity to participate in regular vocational education programs to learn job-specific skills. Vocational assessment should be provided to determine the student's interests and vocational aptitudes. Related services should be provided as necessary to maximize potential for success in a vocational education program. Work experience options should be available to help students bridge the gap between the school program and work. Vocational counseling and job placement and follow-up services should be provided to assist students in securing and maintaining jobs suitable to abilities and interests. Appropriate work activities should be provided to develop work skills for students.

Post-Secondary Transition

The IDEA 97 mandates that each student has transition services included in the IEP no later than age 16 and planning notification of transfer to majority must be made at age 14.   IDEA 97 requires transition services, meaning coordinated activities for a student, designed within an outcome-oriented process, to facilitate transition from school to post-school activities, such as postsecondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, supported employment, continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living, or community participation.  The plan, known as an Individualized Transition Plan (ITP), is part of the IEP process but is a separate component of the IEP.

Transition services are outcomes oriented to plan for the transition from school to post-secondary activities, including post-secondary education, vocational training, integrated employment, supported employment, continuing and adult education, adult services, independent living or community participation. IDEA assures that this plan must take into account the student's preferences and interests.

While it is true that most students, with or without disabilities, are fuzzy about their futures beyond high school, it is critical that plans be made for those with disabilities for many reasons. Traditionally, secondary schools have assumed little responsibility for the preparation of any student for anything but college. U.S. school systems have a curriculum geared to serving college-bound youth, this despite the fact that about 30 percent of U.S. high school graduates matriculate to a 4-year college. The remaining 70% have no real job skills. In any event, the vast majority of students with disabilities will probably not attend college.

The percent of students with disabilities who have been out of school more than one year, and who are working full-time, is 29.2% and those working part-time is 17.2% (National Center for Education Statistics, 1995, p. 112). The average hourly wage earned is $4.35. The students with disabilities most likely to be unemployed are those with mentally retardation, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, other health impairments, visual impairments, multiple disabilities, and deaf-bind. Only 17.3% of these former students live independently. The unemployment rate for those with severe disabilities is about 70 percent. People with disabilities require support and the more severe the disabilities, the more support they need, including personal assistance services, health care coverage, and transportation.

Transition goals in the IEP should provide education programs that teach practical daily living and socialization skills, as well as academic skills. As students near the end of their public school careers, they should have annual goals and objectives related to career education, vocational preparation and community living. As in other IEP's throughout the school years, the students and parents should be involved in goal setting. This may be particularly difficult for some parents who look forward to school completion with a great deal of anxiety. Nonetheless, parents have knowledge about the student that is critical.

According to the United States General Accounting Office (GAO, 1992), the American workplace is changing in response to international competition. Economic change, new technologies and the restructuring of work are resulting in worker dislocation and workers with greater technical skills. They must be versatile and able to adapt to changing conditions--by learning new skills, changing their roles in the workplace, working in teams, sharing management responsibilities, and solving problems. The GAO estimates that one in three youth aged 16 to 24, from among about one million new workers added annually, will not have the skills needed to meet employer requirements for entry-level, semiskilled, high-wage occupations, thus adding to the millions already in the labor market who lack necessary skills.

School-to-Work Opportunities Act of 1994

While there has been concern for years that many students leave school ill-prepared for work, due to the profound changes in the global economy, students may be even worse off than before. The GAO points out that, in contrast to the United States' lack of policy on youth, our principal foreign competitors emphasize that all youth be prepared for work and be ready to adapt to workplace changes.

Probably because of an increased emphasis on academics and the fact that adolescents find vocational education to be socially unacceptable, secondary vocational education has been shrinking. Students are taking fewer vocational courses than in the early 1980's, there are fewer vocational teachers, fewer university programs training them, and fewer state employees work in vocational education. This trend continues even though total secondary enrollments are growing and the vast majority of students do not intend to go to college.

In response to these trends, President Clinton signed the School-to-Work Opportunities Act on May 4, 1994, which authorized funding through 1999 to plan and develop school-to- work programs. The legislation (Sec. 2) noted that "three-fourths of high school students in the United States enter the work force without baccalaureate degrees," and many lack "the academic and entry-level occupational skills necessary to succeed in the changing United States workplace, which is changing in response to heightened international competition and new technologies." Unemployment among U.S. youths is "intolerably high and earnings of high school graduates have been falling relative to earnings of individuals with more education." At the same time, "a substantial number of youths in the United States, especially disadvantaged students, students of diverse racial, ethnic, and cultural backgrounds, and students with disabilities, do not complete high school."

Goals of Vocational Training

There will be many goals and objectives proposed for career education and for specific training. The diversity of the population of students is such that broad goals should be stated for vocational training with more narrow goals and specific objectives identified for each student in the IEP and the IWRP. The following goals are recommend for vocational training:

Integration in the Community

In 1987, the Center on Human Policy, Syracuse University (Research and Training Center on Community Integration, Center on Human Policy, Division of Special Education and Rehabilitation, School of Education, Syracuse University) issued a policy statement that has been used by many to guide planning and policy in the area of community living for adults with developmental disabilities. Below are the major points.

Adults with developmental disabilities should:

Community Housing

Amended after the passage of ADA, the Fair Housing Act 1988 requires that housing units be accessible to people with disabilities. In 1996, the U.S. Department of Justice filed its first suit in the U.S. District Court in Chicago, against an inaccessible condominium in Joilet, Illinois, after a woman using a wheelchair complained she could not find any accessible units there.

Most people with disabilities live with their families or in independent living arrangements and do not receive formal residential services, a dramatic departure from thirty years ago when many state institutions housed millions of Americans with disabilities. For example, of an estimated 7.2 million people with mental retardation, only 308,984 were receiving residential services as of 1993. The most common types of living arrangements are:

Congregate care--Residences owned, rented or managed by the residential services provider to provide housing for persons with disabilities, including care, instruction, supervision and other support.

Family foster care--A home owned or rented by an individual or family in which they live and provide care for one or more unrelated persons with disabilities.

Own home--A home owned or rented by one or more persons in which personal assistance, instruction, supervision and other support is provided as needed (Mangan, Blake, Prouty, & Lakin, 1994).

Many workers with disabilities are going to need considerable support and assistance if they are to maintain the quality of life indicated above. Most other workers are having the same difficulties due to new realities of the global economy.

Although IDEA requires the school to address planning for transition by age 16, the school and parents should begin planning for this transition in the elementary grades. For many children with disabilities, the future chances for gainful employment will be more limited than in the past. The typical former special education student out of high school more than one year is living with his or her family (68.9%) according to the National Center for Educational Statistics, (1995, p. 112). The IEP can be a good way to include important work-related skills early on and to plan transition to the community.

The United States is creating approximately 2 million new jobs each year, but unemployment and underemployment remain serious problems because the jobs that are created are not high paying or secure. At the same time as new jobs have been created, there have been massive layoffs of middle managers and college educated people. Between now and 2005, the U.S. Department of Labor projects that 30 percent of college graduates will be underemployed or unemployed, up 10 percent from 1990. It is imperative that students with disabilities have good vocational training, and they should have apprenticeship programs to increase their chances of employment. The best approach is to get job experience through internships and cooperative education.

For most people, regardless of their jobs, good manners, a work ethic, good grooming, and a pleasing personality are critical work skills. Except in times of downsizing, most people who lose their jobs do so because of personality conflicts or rule violations. In some cases it may be decided that students should attend sheltered workshops and work activity centers, where they may learn important skills. However, it is important to consider competitive employment in integrated settings.

Post-Secondary Transition Team

In general the transition team will have three general options: (1) transition to other schools, (2) transition to competitive employment, and (3) transition to supported employment.

The goal for most students will be an integrated setting for work, where persons without disabilities are also employed. Students should be involved in regular vocational and academic classrooms, actual work in the community, and vocational exploration. Integrated settings contain more typical conditions that promote the acquisition of skills a student will require to be successful in any future job. Some students should also be prepared for college entrance or post-secondary vocational training. Training can take many forms.

The post-secondary team functions much like other IEP teams. It is may be comprised of representatives from rehabilitation services, public health, community agencies concerned with employment, employment services, prospective employers, social security, and others, as necessary. The team's purpose is to plan for future settings and the associated, support, training, education, and evaluation a student will need in moving from the school setting to another. Goals and objectives will be determined, and evaluation of the processes will be included, as well as individuals and groups responsible for implementing the plan to achieve goals. Much of the information necessary for making planning decisions will come from persons outside the school, those with the expertise to assist in planning.

Various programs and activities may begin during school or shortly after school completion. These may be orientation experiences, career exploration, job training, employment evaluation, and special high school programming that is work related. There are many possibilities, each determined by local and state resource. Obviously, students residing in some communities will have a wider array of options than students in more rural areas. Nonetheless, there are several possibilities, and many of them are related to the various programs at the federal level. One of the most successful is cooperative education, a structured method of instruction whereby students alternate or parallel their high school or postsecondary studies, including required academic and vocational courses, with a job in a field related to their academic or occupational objectives.

Training at Employment Sites

Students develop skills for real jobs and learn appropriate work and social behaviors through interactions with co-workers that occur naturally in a work setting. There are many possible arrangements, like the work-study arrangements, so those students can spend part of the day at school and part of the day at work.

Students who begin to work during school are much more likely to adjust to full-time or part-time competitive employment when school is completed. Such experiences can prepare students for eventual employment, and in many cases the employment experience leads to a job where the student is employed part time.

Job Skills Curriculum

Schools can offer instruction and practice in the skills necessary to obtain jobs using existing vocational programs of the school and/or special programming directed at students with particular needs. Special work training programs have been developed in most high schools for many years, although vocational training has been for students without severe disabilities.

Supported Employment

Originally to assist persons with severe developmental disabilities, supported employment services (The Rehabilitation Amendments of 1986, P.L. 99-506) are now available in every state for a wide range of clients. Finding that persons who entered sheltered workshops commonly never gained competitive employment, the client is, instead, placed in a competitive employment setting at the outset and learns work skills on the job. There is usually a high degree of involvement on the part of the client, who selects a job rather than being "matched" to one.

The student and the student's family can work with the transition team to look for something that takes into account the student's interests, not just the student's apparent skills or abilities. Skilled jobs and entry-level jobs that have a chance for advancement can be more easily targeted. If the student is successfully integrated into the job, the chances for long-term employment are good. Support can include a job coach, trainer, and other considerations in an employment setting. In determining adjustment and satisfaction, the emphasis should not necessarily focus on wages. Taken into account should also be living arrangement, family and social relations, and leisure activities.

These should be considered in the transition plan and used as indicators of adjustment. It may be, for example, those individuals with good jobs and fairly high wages may not be as "happy" or well adjusted as those who have good friends and a better quality of life as determined by other factors.

Small Business Administration

Some people with disabilities who are interested in going into business for themselves may qualify for federal assistance and low cost loans from the Small Business Administration (SBA).

Employment Services

There are currently more than 2,000 local Employment Service (ES) offices located throughout the nation. Helping job seekers with disabilities is a specific responsibility. Each office is required by law to have a specialist trained to work with persons with disabilities.

Social Security

The Social Security Administration pays disability benefits under two programs: the Social Security disability insurance program and the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program. There are a number of special rules for persons who are blind. The rules recognize the severe impact of blindness on a person's ability to work.

The medical requirements for disability payments are the same under both programs and the same process determines a person's disability. While eligibility for Social Security disability is based on prior work under Social Security, SSI disability payments are made on the basis of financial need. And there are other differences in the eligibility rules for the two programs. Social Security disability insurance benefits may be paid to worker under age 65 who have disabilities. In this case, disability means a physical or mental impairment that prevents the applicant from working and is expected to last for at least 12 months or to result in death. Children age 18 or older who were disabled before age 22 also can receive monthly benefits when either parent becomes entitled to retirement payments or dies after having worked long enough under social security. Benefits continue as long as the condition prevents work.

Supplemental security income (SSI) makes monthly payments to people who are aged, disabled, or blind and have limited income and resources (assets). To receive SSI payments for disability, the applicant must meet the social security definition of "disabled" or "blind." To be eligible, the recipient must also meet other rules: live in the U.S. or Northern Mariana Islands, be a U.S. citizen or be in the U.S. legally, and, if disabled, must accept vocational rehabilitation services if offered. People may be eligible for SSI if they have never worked. People who receive SSI benefits can also qualify for social security if they are eligible.

Children and adults with disabilities may qualify for SSI payments. Eligibility is based on limited income and resources. States may add to SSI payments, and may also provide Medicaid, food stamps, and other services. According to the Administration, Disabled means a physical or mental disability that keeps an adult from working, a condition that is expected to last at least a year or to result in death. When deciding has a disability, Social Security examines how a disability affects everyday life. The basic publication for this is Social Security And SSI Benefits For Children With Disabilities (Publication No. 05-10026).

People who live in city or county rest homes, halfway houses, or other public institutions usually cannot get SSI checks. But there are some exceptions. Those who live in a publicly operated community residence serving no more than 16 people, may get SSI. Those living in a public institution mainly to attend approved educational or job training may get SSI.

The basic SSI check is the same nationwide. However, many States add money to the basic check. These include California, Delaware, Hawaii, Iowa, Massachusetts, Montana, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Utah, Vermont, Washington, and Washington, D.C.

The Job Training Partnership Act (JTPA)

The Job Training Partnership Act (JTPA), enacted in 1982 and amended in 1992, is the federal government's principal employment training program. The JTPA was created to prepare youth and unskilled adults for entry into the labor force and to afford job training to economically disadvantaged individuals and others facing serious barriers to employment who are in special need of training to obtain productive employment. Many individuals with disabilities meet the eligibility criteria. JTPA, administered by the Department of Labor, has a $4 billion annual budget, including the Job Corps, dislocated worker programs, and summer youth programs. JTPA is viewed as a relatively successful program because most of those who enroll in the program get jobs.

Vocational Rehabilitation

An agency in each state is responsible for the administration of the programs of vocational rehabilitation, supported employment, and independent living for persons with disabilities. The vocational rehabilitation program is designed to assist eligible persons with disabilities to achieve suitable employment. The supported employment program works with individuals with severe disabilities who require ongoing support services to enter or maintain competitive employment. The independent living program is concerned with persons who have severe disabilities. The purpose is to provide them with independent living in the community and in the home.

All of these programs are funded by both federal and state sources, with most of the funding coming from federal funds. Services provided are similar to the IEP, based on an individualized written rehabilitation program (IWRP) which is developed by the eligible person and a representative of the state agency. Services may include:

The IWRP is agreed upon and signed by the student and the vocational rehabilitation counselor. The components of an
IWRP are: The 1992 Amendments to the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 emphasize maximum coordination between the student¹s IEP and
IWRP. The IWRP should be coordinated with the student¹s IEP to the maximum extent possible. Vocational counseling and guidance can begin as soon as a case is considered active by the agency. If the school transition team works carefully with vocational services, a student may begin to receive evaluations and other services at age 16 while still in the public school. The student would receive and assessment for determining eligibility and Vocational Rehabilitation needs, which would include transportation, equipment, services to family members, interpreter services, reader services, rehabilitation teaching, orientation and mobility, medical services, technology-related services, educational and vocational training plans, placement, and follow-up services.
 
 
The 1992 Amendments to the Rehabilitation Act of 1973
"It is the policy of the United States that all programs, projects and activities receiving assistance under this Act shall be carried out in a manner consistent with the principle of - 
  1.  respect for individual dignity, personal responsibility and  the pursuit of meaningful careers, based on informed choice of individuals with disabilities; 
  2. respect for privacy, rights and equal access (including the use of accessible formats) of an individual; 
  3. inclusion, integration and full participation of individuals;
  4. support for the involvement of a parent, a family member, a guardian, an advocate or an authorized representative, if  the individual with a disability desires, requests, or needs  such support; and 
  5. support for individual and systemic advocacy and community involvement." 

Federal Law and Employment

Similar to laws that apply to the school setting, federal law protects the rights and interests of the disabled in employment-- the job application process, hiring, compensation, advancements, organized labor relations, training and terminating employment. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) stipulates that an employer cannot discriminate against a qualified individual with a disability. It requires that the person with a disability be able to fulfill the essential functions of a particular job. Similarly, ADA requires the employer to provide reasonable accommodations to assist in adjustment to employment.

Employers may not include unreasonable requirements nor unnecessary responsibilities and skills for a job. Employers are also required to make "reasonable accommodations" for employment access and job performance:

As an incentive, an ADA tax credit is available for small businesses. The claim is an annual credit up to $5,000 for eligible access expenditures. There is also a barrier removal tax deduction, up to $15,000 per year for qualified architectural and transportation barrier removal expenses.

Conclusions

Secondary school can be very problematic for students with disabilities, especially those with the least academic talent. The "Carnegie unit," lecture classes, and peer acceptance are potential barriers to inclusion at this level, but mostly the subject-centered curriculum has been viewed as a major obstacle. However, there are trends in secondary education that hold out hope for improvement. Public Law 102-62 caused establishment of the National Education Commission on Time and Learning in 1991 to examine the relationship between time and learning. The Commission has since concluded that high schools are designed incorrectly and do not allow students time required for in depth reflection. They call for changes in the organization of schools, promoting concepts of instruction and organization that are familiar in elementary schools, such as block scheduling and other innovations that would alter instructional grouping and teaching practices. Any practice that permits teachers and students the time to become immersed in subject matter can inspire curricular changes that lead to better instruction for all students, including those with disabilities.


 [Chapter 1] [Chapter 2] [Chapter 3] [Chapter 4] [Chapter 5] [Chapter 6] [Chapter 7] [Chapter 8][Chapter 9] [Chapter 10] [References] [Links] [Home]